Bar Food & RecipesGame Day

Best Pellet Grills: How to Choose a Pellet Grill by Size, Hopper and Controller

How to choose a pellet grill: cooking area, hopper size, Wi-Fi or not and pellet storage, with a mid-size pick, a compact one and a big grill for a crowd.

By Megan Tremblay12 min read

A pellet grill is the cooker for people who want real wood smoke without tending a fire. You fill the hopper, set a temperature, and the grill feeds itself for as long as there are pellets to feed. On a pub line, the stations everybody wanted were the ones that held their heat while you dealt with six other things at once, and a good pellet grill earns its patio space the same way. It sits at 225°F (107°C) through the whole second half while you stay on the couch.

This guide is for anyone buying a first pellet grill, trading up from gas, or shopping for someone who cooks, since mid-November is when grills start turning up on holiday gift lists. The short answer: the best pellet grill for most households is a mid-size model of around 500 sq in with a direct-flame option for searing. Go compact if you cook for two or want to bring it to a tailgate, and go big with Wi-Fi if you feed a crowd most weekends. How the auger, firepot and controller work together is covered in the pellet grill explainer, so this page sticks to choosing one and keeping it fed.

How to choose a pellet grill

Start with two questions: how many people do you usually cook for, and what is the longest cook you plan to do? Most of the decision follows from those. Then check:

  • Cooking area. Compare the main grate, not only the headline total, because some makers count upper racks.
  • Temperature range. A low end around 180°F (82°C) gives you a long, smoky start; a top end around 500°F (260°C) roasts hard and gets close to searing.
  • A way to sear. Pellet heat is mostly convection, so it browns but rarely crusts. A plate that slides open to put food over the flame fixes most of that.
  • Hopper size, matched to your longest cook (more below).
  • The controller. A PID controller holds temperature more tightly than a timed one; Wi-Fi adds remote control.
  • Power. Every pellet grill plugs in to run its auger, fan and controller. You need a grounded outdoor outlet with ground-fault protection near where the grill will live, or a plan for power at a tailgate.
  • Build. A snug lid, a grease bucket you can reach, and a hopper that empties easily.

Best overall: Pit Boss 440

The 440 is the size most households grow into rather than out of. It has 518 sq in of cooking area, a range of 180 to 500°F (82 to 260°C), and a flame broiler plate you can slide open to put food over direct heat from the fire. That plate answers the usual complaint about pellet grills, which is that they smoke and roast beautifully and sear like a warm oven.

For scale, 518 sq in is a little more than two half sheet pans laid side by side. That's a pork butt with sausages beside it, or a full tray of smoked wings for a watch party in one batch. Closed, the plate gives the steady, indirect heat a long cook needs. Open it at the end and the same grill can mark burgers or colour chicken thighs. Treat it like any open flame: fatty food will flare, so stay close.

The trade-off is the hopper. At 5 lb (2.3 kg) it is smaller than the compact grill below, which is fine for wings or a whole chicken but means at least one refill on a long rib or pork butt cook. Keep a dry bag by the back door, and check the listing for the controller type before you assume Wi-Fi.

Budget pick: Pit Boss 150

The 150 is the small one: 256 sq in of cooking area, the same 180 to 500°F (82 to 260°C) range and the same flame broiler idea, sized for a balcony-sized cook or the back of a truck at a tailgate. 256 sq in is roughly one half sheet pan with a little room around it. That covers wings for four, a spatchcocked chicken, or a rack of ribs cut in half to fit.

Its 7 lb (3.2 kg) hopper is bigger than the 440's, which is unusual on a compact grill and handy for the long, low cooks a small household actually does. The limits are the obvious ones. Two pork butts won't fit, a crowd means cooking in rounds, and like every pellet grill it needs electricity, so a tailgate means a generator or a portable power station. Check the maker's power requirements before you trust a battery to carry you through a four-hour cook. And before it goes on a condo balcony, read the building rules: a pellet grill makes real wood smoke, and plenty of buildings treat it like charcoal.

The upgrade: Traeger Woodridge

The Woodridge is for people who cook for a crowd and want to keep an eye on the pit from the couch. It has 860 sq in of cooking area, wood-fired heat and Wi-Fi control, so you can check the temperature and change it from your phone during a timeout without getting up.

860 sq in is more than three and a half half sheet pans. That's room for two pork butts and a couple of racks of ribs at once, or wings for the whole party without batches, which is the real point of a big grill on game day: everything comes off at the same time. Traeger's spec sheet is the place to confirm the hopper capacity and the temperature range, so check both before you plan an overnight cook around it.

The trade-off is size. A big chamber takes more pellets to heat, especially on a cold November evening, and if you usually cook for four, most of that grate is empty steel you are warming for nothing. Measure the patio, the path from the garage and the reach of your outdoor outlet before it arrives.

Traeger's grills are also sold by Abt, a family-owned appliance store in Illinois, alongside other pellet brands. It is a handy place to put the Woodridge next to Traeger's smaller models and check which size really fits your patio.

Also good

Pellets first. The Traeger Signature Blend is an all-purpose mix of hickory, maple and cherry in an 18 lb (8.2 kg) bag, and the maker says it suits any pellet grill, not only its own. Hickory gives pork and beef some backbone, while maple and cherry keep it gentle enough for chicken, which makes it a sensible first bag while you work out what you like.

The Traeger Stay Dry bin holds about 22 lb (10 kg) of pellets behind a locking lid, so a full 18 lb bag fits with room to spare. It is a plain, useful thing to buy alongside any pellet grill, because damp pellets swell and jam augers, and an auger jam halfway through a pork butt is a long afternoon. If the grill is a holiday gift, add the bag and the bin, and the first cook can happen the day it is built.

Pellet grill vs gas

Pellet grill Gas grill
Heat source Hardwood pellets, fed by an auger and fan Propane or natural gas burners
Needs power Yes, an outdoor outlet No, or a small battery for the igniter
Wood flavour Real smoke, strongest at low settings Very little
Low and slow Holds 225°F (107°C) for hours Possible with a smoker box and fiddling
Searing Fair; much better with a direct-flame plate Good, best with a sear zone
Start-up A few minutes to light, then a preheat Light and preheat
Upkeep Firepot ash, grease tray, dry pellets Burners, grease tray, tank checks
Cold weather Burns more pellets A propane tank delivers less gas in deep cold

The pellet grill vs gas question comes down to what you cook on a Tuesday. If it's mostly burgers, chops and chicken breasts done in 20 minutes, gas lights faster and sears harder. If your weekends are ribs, pork butt and a holiday turkey, a pellet grill does those with far less work than any other smoker and can still turn out burgers on a weeknight.

Wings are where the pellet grill pulls ahead: smoke them low, then turn the dial up to crisp the skin without moving them, the method in smoked chicken wings with skin that snaps.

Cooking area: what the numbers mean

Grill Cooking area Roughly the size of Comfortable for
Pit Boss 150 256 sq in (1,650 sq cm) One half sheet pan, with room around it 2 to 4 people
Pit Boss 440 518 sq in (3,340 sq cm) Just over two half sheet pans 4 to 8 people
Traeger Woodridge 860 sq in (5,550 sq cm) Over three and a half half sheet pans 8 or more

A half sheet pan is 18 by 13 in (46 by 33 cm), about 234 sq in, and holding one up in your kitchen is the quickest way to picture a grate. The last column is a rough guide for a game-day spread, not a rule.

A pellet grill cooks by moving hot air, so food packed edge to edge cooks unevenly; leave a finger or two of room between pieces. Shape matters too, since a long brisket needs length, not just square inches. Buy for the biggest cook you do a few times a year, not the biggest you can imagine, because a bigger grill burns more pellets every single time.

Hopper size and how long a load lasts

The hopper sets how long the grill can run without you. Pellet use rises and falls with the setting and the weather: a low smoke setting on a still afternoon sips, and high heat in a cold wind gulps. Makers commonly quote somewhere around 1 to 3 lb (0.5 to 1.4 kg) an hour, which puts a 5 lb hopper at a few hours of cooking and a 7 lb hopper at a little more. Use that as a planning range, not a promise.

The practical habit is simple: start every long cook with a full hopper and look at it each time you check the meat. For a pork butt or ribs, the smoker time calculator works back from when you want to eat to when the meat goes on, which also tells you how many hours of pellets you need on hand. On a cold night, plan for the top of the range.

A bigger hopper is not automatically better. Pellets left in a hopper for weeks pull moisture out of the air, so you want enough capacity for your usual long cook and a quick way to empty the rest into a dry bin afterward. Many grills have a clean-out door or chute for that; check the listing.

Wi-Fi controllers: worth it on game day?

What Wi-Fi gives you is distance. You can see the pit temperature from the couch, and on grills that take meat probes, the meat temperature too, and change the setting without going outside. On a long cook that runs into the game, that is most of the appeal: the lid stays shut and you stay in your seat.

Three things to weigh:

  1. Signal. A grill at the far end of the yard, behind a brick wall, may sit at the edge of your home Wi-Fi. Check where the router is before you choose a spot for the grill.
  2. The app. You will be using the maker's app and account, with updates that arrive on the maker's schedule.
  3. It is still a fire. A phone alert won't empty a grease bucket. Follow the maker's guidance on leaving the grill unattended, and go out and look at it now and then, especially at high heat.

If the grill you want has no Wi-Fi, a leave-in wireless meat thermometer gives you much of the same comfort. It can't change the grill's temperature remotely, which matters less than you'd expect once a grill holds steady.

Pellet storage through a Canadian winter

Pellets are compressed sawdust, and all winter long they are trying to turn back into it. A few habits keep them hard and glossy until spring:

  • Keep them in a lidded bin, off the floor, in a dry garage, shed or basement. A torn bag on concrete is how you end up with a bucket of mush in March.
  • Pour from the top of the bag and leave the dust at the bottom out of the hopper. Sift it if there is much.
  • Empty the hopper if the grill will sit for more than a couple of weeks, and always before it goes under a cover for the winter.
  • Brush snow off the hopper lid before you open it. Wet snow melting into the pellets is the fastest route to a jammed auger.

Cooking through the cold is fine, but the grill burns more fuel when the air is cold and the wind is up, so park it somewhere sheltered and expect to refill. Sheltered never means a garage or a covered porch: burning pellets give off carbon monoxide. If you add an insulated blanket, use one made for your grill. For the other side of winter care, the firepot ash and the grease tray, see how to clean a grill.

How we chose

We have not cooked on these particular grills. The picks come from the makers' published details (cooking area, temperature range, hopper capacity, the flame broiler plate on the Pit Boss models and Wi-Fi control on the Traeger), from what owners commonly report about pellet grills as a group, such as pellets jamming after damp storage and fuel use climbing in cold weather, and from years of cooking on commercial line equipment and live fire. We chose one grill at each common size, so the choice comes down to how many people you feed, and where the makers' details leave a gap, such as the hopper on the largest pick, we point you to the spec sheet.

FAQ

Is a pellet grill worth it?

If you want to smoke ribs, pork and wings without managing a fire, yes: nothing else gets you real wood flavour for so little attention. If you mostly grill thin, quick food on weeknights, a gas grill lights faster and sears harder.

Is a pellet smoker the same as a pellet grill?

Yes. The two names describe the same machine, and makers use them interchangeably. It smokes at low settings and grills or roasts at high ones.

Can a pellet grill sear a steak?

Not as well as charcoal or a hot gas grill, because the heat is mostly convection. A direct-flame option like the slide plate on the Pit Boss picks helps a lot, and a cast iron pan preheated on the grates covers the rest.

What size pellet grill do I need?

For two to four people, around 250 sq in is enough. For most families and small watch parties, around 500 sq in. If you regularly cook for eight or more, or want two big cuts on at once, look at 800 sq in and up.

Do I have to use the same brand of pellets as my grill?

Generally no, as long as they are food-grade hardwood cooking pellets and your grill's manual doesn't say otherwise. Heating pellets made for pellet stoves are a different product, so keep them away from the grill.